Yep, it’s true. He is by every definition of the word, a civilian contractor and he is a Medal of Honor recipient. Matter of fact, he, along with several other famous wild west legends were contractors as well. Men like Robert Denbow, David L. Payne, and Wild Bill Hickok were all civilian Scouts hired by the US Army to hunt and kill Indians during that long war for the west. Not to mention the hundreds of Indians hired by the US Army to be Scouts.
What they paid these guys back then was interesting too. Cody was getting paid I believe 5 dollars a day, versus 12 dollars a month for the enlisted man in the Army. (sound familiar?) In essence, Cody and the rest of the mountain men Scouts employed by the US Army were well compensated and highly valued contractors back in the day. I am not sure how much they paid the Indian Scouts, but I am sure they paid pretty well for that too. Scouts were certainly an asset back then, and worth every penny.
On a side note, I have been reading the book Indian Wars, and have been very interested in that war’s activities. Especially how the tactics evolved over the course of many years of fighting, and how important the use of Indian and Mountain Man Scouts were to that effort. Arguably, the US Army back in the day, would never have defeated the Native American without these civilian contractor Scouts.
That war went through the same typical ‘arc of learning’ that we painfully go through in every war, and in the beginning it was all about using conventional forces to combat guerilla forces. We learned slowly, after years of combat with the Native American, that conventional warfare like that, just doesn’t work against light and nimble guerilla forces.
In this war, we got small and mobile, and used Indian Scouts that hated a rival Indian tribe, and it worked. It reminds me a lot of how the Selous Scouts operated in Rhodesia, by using captured and turned guerillas for operations. General George Crook and Kit Carson is definitely worth some more investigation, if you are interested in the Scout concept as it was applied during the Indian Wars.
Also, thanks to Cannoneer#4 for all the enlightening input about Scouts during the Indian Wars on prior posts. I learn a lot from ‘you’ the readership, and your input is highly valued. Cheers. –Matt
Edit: Also, I mean no disrespect to my Native American readership. This is purely a study on military tactics and military history, and the use of contractors in past wars. But along those lines, it was a war and it does deserve some study so we can learn from it. I also have great respect for Crazy Horse and Geronimo, and we can learn a lot about how they conducted operations as well.
——————————————————————-
Buffalo Bill Cody – Congressional Medal of Honor Holder
By Carl Benjamin
Earlier this year I did an article for Associated Content on Buffalo Bill’s Wild West Show and the many characters that performed with him. Over the course of my research, I discovered that Buffalo Bill Cody was awarded the Congressional Medal of Honor. This is something that I never knew about or even understood why and how he received it.
William Cody was born in 1846 in Iowa. Quite a bit is known about young Bill Cody. After the death of his brother, the family moved to Kansas. His family was often persecuted because they believed in fighting anti-slavery. His father was stabbed while giving an anti-slavery speech. He never fully recovered. At the age of 11, Cody took a job with a freight company as a “boy extra”. His job was to ride up and down the wagon train delivering messages. He later joined Johnson’s Army as a scout. His job was to help guide the Army in Utah. It is here that he got his reputation as an ‘Indian fighter.” Sometime between the age of 12 and 14 he killed his first Indian. At the age of 14 he signed on with the “Pony Express.” Before he became a rider, he helped build the stations and corrals and took care of the livestock. In 1863 , after the death of his mother, he enlisted with the Union Army and entered the Civil War.(In 1863 he enlisted as a teamster with the rank of Private in Company H, 7th Kansas Cavalry and served until discharged in 1865. From 1868 until 1872 Cody was employed as a scout by the United States Army.)
From 1868-1872 he was a scout with the 3rd Calvary Regiment. He also worked part time for the Kansas Pacific Railroad. During this time, he would scout for the Army and kill bison for the railroad.
Congressional Medal of Honor: He achieved this honor on April 26, 1872 for gallantry in action at Platte River, Nebraska.(Battle of Summit Springs) On July 11, 1869, Cody killed Chief Tall Bull and rescued a captured white woman. The skirmish was between the 5th Army and the Cheyenne Dog Soldiers. Tall bull was the leader of the Cheyenne. The Army was outnumbered 450 to 244 on that day. At the time, he was a civilian scout, working for the Army. He was a member of the Pawnee Scouts. This was during the Indian Wars. On February 5th, 1917, 24 days after Cody’s’ death, the medal was revoked. It was decided that because he was a civilian, he wasn’t eligible for the award. However the medal was restored to him by the Army in 1989.
A line of thought; The Medal of Honor was first established for heroic acts. It didn’t matter who you were. Later it was only to go to those who did heroic deeds during major battles fought by the US. That is why about 900 had the award revoked. However, over the course of time, the Medal of Honor was reshaped especially for military acts of honor. Bill Cody just happened to fall in with a group at the time that this was taking place. At the time, many people were outraged that the government would do this to such an American Legend as Buffalo Bill Cody. When he was nominated, he was nominated because he had fulfilled what an honoree was required to do.
Buffalo Bill is no doubt a legend of the old west. There are stories both fact and fiction about his exploits. However, the Indian Wars were documented. What happened on that 11th of July in 1869 at Summit Springs is recorded history. Some of the details might be a bit sketchy. The bottom line is though, that his efforts that day thrust him into an honor that very few receive.
William Cody (Buffalo Bill) was a freight driver, Buffalo hunter, Indian fighter, Army Scout, Pony express rider, stagecoach driver, Civil War Vet, Wild west show manager, and a congressional Medal of Honor recipient.
Story here.
Wikipedia for Buffalo Bill here.
thanks for this interesting article. I am doing some research and I was wondering about the origin of your sources. I am particularly interested in Cody being a contractor or any other proof that these guys were army contractors. I d be gratefull if you could send me some of your sources,
cheers.
Comment by Dvp — Wednesday, March 3, 2010 @ 1:40 AM
DVP,
No problem, and I enjoy bringing up this aspect of American history. Probably the best sources you can use for your research are online or some current books you can buy on Amazon.
One book that I have enjoyed about William Cody, is this one. It goes into detail about his Wild West Shows, which I think is particularly interesting. Here he was, an Civilian Scout or White Indian, and back then these guys were met with some criticism. Either people thought that these white scouts were turned and working for the native american, or a traitor to the 'white race' (this is how it was framed in the books). Or there were the scam artists back then that offered their services as civilian scouts, who instead just robbed their clients. They were called Confidence Men or Con-men.
To alleviate those fears back then, and to also redeem the value of those civilian scouts that did good and heroic things, William Cody put together the Wild West show which highlighted the many things that made the West so interesting to the rest of the world.
Plus, there was no such thing as the internet or 24 hour news, or even movie theaters back then. It was all live theater back then, and the Wild West show was a mobile theater system. Circuses were also the same.
The point is, William Cody was trying to promote the good things that Scouts did, and that they were heroes and a big part of the west. It also helped out his business as a scout, because everyone wanted to be protected by the master William Cody.
Here is the book, and please check out the other books for your research.
http://www.amazon.com/Buffalo-Bills-America-Willi…
Comment by headjundi — Wednesday, March 3, 2010 @ 12:48 PM
Oh, and on a side note. Did you know that the preferred scout transportation back then on the high plains was not a horse, but a mule? lol I can just picture Cody on a mule.
The significance about that, is that Cody was a hybrid. A cross between a white man with indian-like skills. He was not a cross-breed, he was just naturally gifted as a tracker and hunter. The mule is a hybrid as well, and a cross between a horse and a donkey. That hybrid combination of scout and mule, is what led all the settlers and all the military units, across thousands of miles of plains, through all those thousands of fights with indians.
These scouts also wore buckskin like todays contractors wear 5.11 tactical pants. It was the scout uniform back then, and it made them stand out at train stations when they were offering their services to offloaded investors or homesteaders. They all tried to look the part, much like EP agents wear the suit and Rolex watches to look the part of a protector.
Comment by headjundi — Wednesday, March 3, 2010 @ 12:55 PM