Feral Jundi

Thursday, September 17, 2009

Industry Talk: The Difference Between Fault and Responsibility, by Jake Allen

   Excellent post by Jake about the AGNA stuff, and the difference between fault and responsibility. Check it out, and this was also posted at Combat Operator and Private Military Herald. –Matt

——————————————————————

The Difference Between Fault and Responsibility

Sep 16, 2009

By Jake Allen

The more I read about our government in the mainstream media the more I realize how neither one seems to understand the difference between ‘fault’ and ‘responsibility’.  The ArmorGroup fiasco at the U.S. Embassy in Kabul is only the latest incident but I will use it here because it is fresh on everyone’s mind and it is particularly illustratrative.

It’s critically important that we separate the terms fault and responsibility. Sometimes a person or an entity is both ‘at fault’ and ‘responsible’ but the two are not synonymous.  In other words there is room for ‘blame’ or ‘fault’ at both ArmorGroup and at the State Department but the ‘responsibility’ for what happened only comes down in one place.

There is little doubt that the antics being conducted primarily by C-shift on the expatriate guard force was nearly 100% the doing of immature and poorly supervised and lead ArmorGroup contractors.  ArmorGroup is ‘at fault’ for hiring these low-end nonprofessionals.

(more…)

Wednesday, September 16, 2009

Media News: Death and Politics For Contractors–A Cautionary Tale

Filed under: Iraq,Media News — Tags: , , , — Matt @ 12:51 PM

Adam Hermanson 

Security contractor Adam Hermanson at the Swords of Qadisiyyah in Zawra Park, Iraq.

Death and Politics For Contractors–A Cautionary Tale

09/16/2009

     The other day I was watching a show called Democracy Now headlined by Amy Goodman and Jeremy Scahill, and I was appalled.  They had the family of Adam Hermanson on the show, and the supposed focus was the accidental death of Adam Hermanson in Iraq.  You would think the show would be centered on who did the electrical work that caused the death of this security contractor?  Or maybe even a focus on the lack of management and quality control by the contracting officers and construction company that was tasked with building Camp Olympia and it’s facilities?  But that wasn’t the case, and instead it was a disgusting display of politics.

(more…)

Monday, September 14, 2009

Legal News: My Thoughts on Saleh Vs. Titan/CACI

     First off, I am not posting this to say that contractors are above the law or that we should not be held accountable.  I want us to be held accountable and to serve honorably. But does that mean that all of our rights and legal protections should be thrown out with the bath water?  I don’t think so, nor will I support that.

     I also think that being covered by the UCMJ is appropriate, just as long as the military exercises that right to use UCMJ for matters concerning contractors.  We are also accountable to the various SOFA’s out there, so to say that we are above the law is just not true.

(more…)

Film: The Video Game ‘Army of Two’ to be Made Into a Movie

Filed under: Film,Games,Industry Talk — Tags: , , , , — Matt @ 1:49 PM

“The ambiguity of these private military corporations lends weight to an intelligent thriller with relevance to what’s going on in the world right now. You have contractors with their own agendas, and two guys whose friendship supersedes all the politics.”

     Wow, so the guy who wrote the Bourne Ultimatum, Scott Burns, is writing the script for Army of Two?  And he wants to give it a serious treatment?  Wow, and I applaud that. So will this film be like Tango and Cash, Harley Davidson and the Marlboro Man, Starsky and Hutch, (fill in favorite action buddy film)? lol

     Although I am highly skeptical of what the end product will really be.  Unfortunately, hollywood is on the kick of defining PMC’s and PSC’s as evil.  Would they and could they actually give the subject fair treatment?  I wonder what the investors have to say about what the ‘correct’ money making view on PMC’s and PSC’s should be?

(more…)

Saturday, September 12, 2009

Legal News: Court Dismisses Iraqi Contractor Torture Case

Filed under: Iraq,Legal News — Tags: , , , , , , , — Matt @ 8:15 AM

“During wartime, where a private service contractor is integrated into combatant activities over which the military retains command authority, a tort claim arising out of the contractor’s engagement in such activities shall be preempted,” Judge Laurence Silberman said in the ruling. 

   This is big, and this is the kind of good news the contracting community needs.  Precedents like this are what we need for further protection in the future for similar cases.  I would be interested to hear what some of our legal experts that read FJ have to say about this one. –Matt

Edit:  By the way, for all of Scahill’s readers that have come to FJ from his blog, welcome.  If you would like to have a rational discussion about the positives or negatives of this ruling, I am all for that. That even includes Jeremy Scahill, if he is game.

    I thought it was good news,  because it symbolizes that we do fall under the authority of the military.  Since 2007, we have fallen under UCMJ, and this ruling further enforces that concept.

   Oh, and don’t forget to check out my latest post on my thoughts about the ruling.  I am interested in what you guys, or any of my readers have to say about it and here is the link.

——————————————————————

Court dismisses Iraqi contractor torture case

Fri Sep 11, 2009 2:50pm EDT

By James Vicini

WASHINGTON (Reuters) – A federal appeals court on Friday dismissed a lawsuit against two U.S. defense contractors by Iraqi torture victims, saying the companies had immunity as government contractors.

The lawsuit was filed in 2004 on behalf of Iraqi nationals who say they or their relatives had been tortured or mistreated while detained by the U.S. military at the Abu Ghraib prison.

(more…)

« Newer PostsOlder Posts »

Powered by WordPress